Skip to content

Comparison of two hops

El Dorado or Simcoe?

El Dorado (United States, 2010) and Simcoe (United States, 2000) are both dual-purpose hops, bittering and aromatic. Their alpha acids are of the same order (13–17% for El Dorado, 12–14% for Simcoe). Dominant aromas: sweet fruit, citrus, woody and resinous for El Dorado; citrus, sweet fruit, floral for Simcoe (in common: sweet fruit, citrus). Simcoe is among the published substitutes for El Dorado. On the growing side, El Dorado is presumed protected (registered name), Simcoe is free to use (protection expired).

Superimposed aromas

● Citrus● Sweet fruit● Green fruit● Red berries● Cream, caramel● Woody, resinous● Menthol● Herbal● Spicy● Grassy, hay● Vegetal● Floral

● El Dorado® (BarthHaas) · ● Simcoe® (Crosby Hops). Solid line: published intensities (0–5). Hollow ring: family cited without intensity. An axis that was not rated is not plotted. Two different sources do not necessarily score on the same basis.

Swapping one for the other

For bitterness, the dose is set by alpha acids: the replacement quantity equals the planned quantity multiplied by the alpha of the original variety, divided by the alpha of the replacement. With the published averages, 100 g of El Dorado (15%) give the same bitterness as about 115 g of Simcoe (13%).

The alpha of a lot varies from one harvest to the next: the calculation uses the value printed on the bag. For aroma additions (end of boil, dry hopping), the same quantity is generally kept; the profile changes, as the wheel shows.

What to use instead of El Dorado · What to replace Simcoe with

El Dorado and Simcoe side by side · published values, bars on a common scale

El Dorado®Simcoe®
Usedual-purposedual-purpose
Country of originUnited StatesUnited States
Year of release20102000
Alpha acids13–17%12–14%
Beta acids7–8%4–5%
Cohumulone28–33%15–20%
Total oil (ml/100 g)2.5–3.3 ml/100 g2–2.5 ml/100 g
Myrcene55–60%60–65%
Humulene10–15%10–15%
Caryophyllene6–8%5–8%
Farnesene0.1 %0–1%
Dominant aromassweet fruit, citrus, woody and resinouscitrus, sweet fruit, floral
Described aromasTropical fruit flavours, pineapple, mango. Aromas of peach, watermelon, yellow fruit and candyBright citrus flavours with earthy undertones, grapefruit, pine and herb aromas
Beer stylesIPA, Wheat beerPale ale, IPA, Double IPA (imperial IPA)
Resistant tonot publisheddowny mildew, powdery mildew
Susceptible tonot publishednot published
StorageRetains 60–75% of its alpha acids after 6 months at 20 °CRetains 70–80% of its alpha acids after 6 months at 20 °C
Protectionpresumed protectedtitle expired
On sale in Francenot on sale yetnot on sale yet

Values copied from the two variety pages; “not published” when no source gives it. Dominant aromas: the three most intense families from the cited source, or the families cited. Method: method and sources. Directory updated on Thursday 19 November 2026.

Other comparisons

Citra or Simcoe · Mosaic or Simcoe · Simcoe or Southern Cross · Simcoe or Triskel

All comparisons · compare up to four varieties · all varieties